Skip to content
HorseAcre Logo
HorseAcre REAL ESTATE BUILT AROUND THE HORSE.
Hallmark Farm
HomePropertiesMillbrook, NY

Hallmark Farm

Butts Hollow Rd, Millbrook, NY
ESTATE HIGHLIGHTS

Property & Equestrian Overview

70 /100
HORSESCORE Established Equestrian Estate
185 ACRES
9 BEDROOMS
9.5 BATHS
13,982 SQ FT
10 STALLS
EQUESTRIAN AT A GLANCE
10-Stall
Equine Barn
Riding & Training
Arena Footing
185.0 Ac
Land & Pastures
Turnout Paddocks
Fenced Turnout
Water Infrastructure
Water to Fields
Wash & Prep Area
Wash & Grooming
PREVIOUSLY $20 MILLION. NOW SELLING AT OR ABOVE $7.95 MILLION!
NOW SELLING AT OR ABOVE $7.95 MILLION!
— Platinum Luxury Auctions, HorseAcre
Set within the rolling hills of Millbrook Hunt Country and framed by sweeping panoramic mountain views, this extraordinary country estate encompasses approximately 185 private acres in one of the Hudson Valley’s most established sporting landscapes. Once the cherished country retreat and Elk preserve of industrialist and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie’s only child, Margaret Carnegie. The property carries a distinguished legacy that continues to shape its character today. Originally constructed in 1865, the property has been thoughtfully expanded and renovated over time, preserving its historic significance while introducing modern comforts and amenities suited to contemporary living. Spanning more than 13,700 sf across multiple structures, the estate offers a total of nine bedrooms, nine full baths, and one half bath. An updated main residence combines grand entertaining spaces with inviting everyday living areas, including a richly paneled library with a fireplace, a formal dining room capable of hosting up to 30 guests, and a dramatic living room with soaring 20-ft ceilings, a fireplace, and French doors that open to a terrace with extraordinary mountain views. A renovated chef’s kitchen features Viking and Bosch appliances, a breakfast room, and spaces designed for both large gatherings and casual family meals. Upstairs, the primary suite includes a sitting room, dressing room, and private bath, while additional bedrooms provide the perfect interplay of past and present. Modern enhancements, including an elevator and carefully integrated expansions, complement the residence’s historic architecture. The estate’s equestrian facilities are equally impressive. Designed by renowned French architectural firm Atelier Choiseul, the equestrian facilities include a 10-stall barn with a tack room, staff housing, and a refined lounge, plus meticulously maintained paddocks ranging from six to twelve acres, e
FACILITIES OVERVIEW

Equestrian Facilities & Infrastructure

5 Verified Equine Features
Stalls & Barn
10 Stalls (Main Barn)
Riding Arena
Riding & Training Facilities
Pasture & Fencing
185.0 Acres Fenced
Water & Access
Ag Well & Trailer Access
Tack Room / Saddle Lounge
Barn & Stabling
Individual Turnout Paddocks
Fencing & Pastures
Year-Round Creek / Stream
Water Features & Land
In-Ground Spa / Hot Tub
Water Features & Land
Primary Luxury Estate Residence
Housing & Security
Contact for Price
Listing Price
For Auction
ESTATE ARCHITECTURE & LIVING

The Residence & Private Grounds

Estate Showcase
9 Bedrooms
9.5 Baths
13,982 Sq Ft
Established Estate
Bedrooms / Baths
9 Bed / 9.5 Bath
Living Area
13,982 Sq Ft
Garage & Parking
Ample Parking & Storage
Special Amenities
Equestrian Estate Living

Residence & Interior Features

13,982 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space
9 bedrooms with 9.5 baths and primary suite
Secondary guest house / staff quarters with private entrance
Gourmet chef's kitchen with premium finishes and dining area
Fireplace and open living room overlooking grounds and pastures
EQUESTRIAN ENVIRONS & LOCAL AMENITIES

Area Map, Vets, Venues & Schools

Butts Hollow Rd, Millbrook, NY

39 Nearby Landmarks • 10 Regional Listings
Equine Vet / Hospital
Available upon inquiry
Major Show Venue
Available upon inquiry
Local School
1.4 mi to Greer School
Airport & Jet FBO
Available upon inquiry
Feed & Tack Supply
Available upon inquiry
Medical Center
Available upon inquiry

Verified Local Facilities & Distances

Click any location to locate on map
Equine Veterinary & Surgical Hospitals
Regional equine veterinary and surgical center distances available upon inquiry.
Equestrian Venues & Showgrounds
Major equestrian competition and arena distances available upon inquiry.
Local Public & Private Schools
Greer School
Public / Private School
1.4 mi
~3 min drive
Dutchess Day School
Public / Private School
1.9 mi
~3 min drive
Bell School
Public / Private School
4.8 mi
~8 min drive
Wassaic State School
Public / Private School
5.6 mi
~8 min drive
Clove School
Public / Private School
5.9 mi
~8 min drive
Millbrook School
Public / Private School
7.8 mi
~11 min drive
Airports & Executive Aviation (FBO)
Regional municipal airport and executive FBO travel times available upon request.
Feed, Hay & Tack Outfitters
Nearby feed, hay, and farm outfitter locations available upon inquiry.
Regional Emergency & Medical Centers
Regional emergency medical and trauma center distances available upon inquiry.
CURATED SELECTION

Similar Equestrian Listings

Explore All Properties
Custom Farmhouse & 6 Stall Barn on 20 Acres
For Sale
$2,499,000
Citra, FL
Custom Farmhouse & 6 Stall Barn on 20 Acres
20.0 Acres 6 Stalls
The Quarry Estate-Waterfront Equestrian Retreat
For Sale
$7,849,000
Citra, FL
The Quarry Estate-Waterfront Equestrian Retreat
132.0 Acres 5 Stalls
63 Acre Luxury Equestrian Custom Home!
For Sale
$3,980,000
Micanopy, FL
63 Acre Luxury Equestrian Custom Home!
63.3 Acres 12 Stalls
47 +/- Acres Turn-key Equestrian Facility
For Sale
$2,679,000
Reddick, FL
47 +/- Acres Turn-key Equestrian Facility
47.0 Acres 56 Stalls
150 acres Luxury Equestrian Farm near WEC
For Sale
$3,995,000
Reddick, FL
150 acres Luxury Equestrian Farm near WEC
150.0 Acres 7 Stalls
Luxury Living. Equestrian Excellence.
For Sale
$2,950,000
Ocala, FL
Luxury Living. Equestrian Excellence.
29.6 Acres 5 Stalls
21.75 Acres in Central Florida Horse Country
For Sale
$5,900,000
Geneva, FL
21.75 Acres in Central Florida Horse Country
21.8 Acres 5 Stalls
Zoelyon | Equestrian Estate with 5 Stall Barn
For Sale
$9,000,000
Chuluota, FL
Zoelyon | Equestrian Estate with 5 Stall Barn
13.8 Acres 5 Stalls
Property photo
70

HorseScore Analysis

Established Equestrian Estate

HorseScore evaluates over 30 equine, land, and facility benchmarks to deliver an objective rating of equestrian readiness, functionality, and market value.

Barn & Stabling 18 / 20 pts
Acreage & Pastures 20 / 20 pts
Riding & Training 4 / 20 pts
Location & Equestrian Environs 10 / 15 pts
Trails & Water Infrastructure 12 / 15 pts
Estate & Accommodations 6 / 10 pts
Equine Benchmark: Score reflects stabling capacity, turnout/pasture acreage, arena footings, safety fencing, riding trails, and water infrastructure.